Este site utiliza cookies

Dados necessários para melhorar nosso serviço e personalizar a sua experiência.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Market Roundup: Are stock options salaries or business transactions?

Market Roundup: Are stock options salaries or business transactions?

Brazil’s second-highest judicial body will decide whether stock options should be interpreted as part of executives’ salaries or as a parallel business transaction between them and the company

(Photo: Roman Samborskyi)

By Fabiane Ziolla Menezes

Mar 30, 2024

  • 🔔 The dashboard: Brazil’s benchmark stock index Ibovespa gained 0.85 percent this week. Meanwhile, the Brazilian real lost 0.32 percent against the U.S. dollar.
  • Biggest gains: São Martinho (energy):  9.26 percent
  • Biggest drops: Petz (retail): -11.94 percent

Brazil’s second-highest court may change its view on stock options

The Superior Court of Justice (STJ), Brazil’s second-highest judicial body, is about to decide whether stock options offered as benefits to executives should be legally interpreted as part of their salaries or as a parallel commercial agreement between them and the company.

The decision will serve as a reference for all litigation on the issue.. More than 500 lawsuits in various courts have been stayed pending the STJ’s decision.

State of play. The decision will determine how and when stock options will be taxed.

  • Up to 27.5 percent at the time the employee buys the shares, or at 15 percent and only when the shares are sold — in which case the tax would only be levied if there is a capital gain on the transaction (i.e., if the share value increases during the period).

Mixed signals. While the labor court system has a track record of favorable decisions for taxpayers — which read stock option plans as commercial transactions — the tax appeals court, Carf, has often ruled in the opposite direction.

  • Mariana Dias Arello, a tax lawyer at Briganti Advogados, points to two aspects that support the labor courts’ understanding: stock option plans involve risks, as the employee does not necessarily make a profit from the transaction, and they are voluntary, as the employee is not forced to acquire the shares after the grace period.

Limited reach. On the other hand, by considering stock options as wages, Carf has insisted on the incidence not only of income tax but also of social security contributions on these securities. The STJ, however, has refrained from discussing said contributions on stock options; it will only decide on the nature of the transactions and the type of income tax to which they will be subject.

Why it matters. The STJ ruling may change the way companies in Brazil use stock options to attract new talent and leaders, especially C-level executives.

  • Camila Pelizaro de Arruda Camargo, a tax lawyer at Lopes Muniz, says that recognizing the operation as a commercial transaction would provide more legal certainty for companies to grant such benefits, which could contribute to an increase in the practice.

The devil is in the details. Luis Eduardo Maneira, another tax lawyer, says that for the ruling to be effective, the STJ will have to define the necessary requirements to characterize a stock option plan as a commercial transaction.

  • Likewise, the decision may include criteria that indicate plans with a remunerative nature, as these plans “vary greatly from one company to another.”
  • In other words, the court will not necessarily decide one thing to the detriment of another.

Yes, but … The STJ decision may not be the end of the discussion. A bill that would establish rules for stock option plans was approved by the Senate in 2022 and has been stuck in the House since last September. Experts expect the STJ ruling to influence the vote on the bill in Congress.

  • The bill defines stock option plans as commercial transactions.

What’s next? The nine-judge STJ panel still has to set a trial date.

https://brazilian.report/business/2024/03/30/stock-options-salaries-business-transactions/

Veja outras notícias relacionadas



Receita Federal quer ampliar em 30 dias recolhimento da CBS
Imprensa

Receita Federal quer ampliar em 30 dias recolhimento da CBS

12 de novembro de 2026

A Receita Federal pretende levar ao Congresso Nacional um projeto de lei complementar para facilitar o recolhimento da Contribuição sobre Bens e Serviços (CBS) em 2027. O Valor Econômico repercutiu o assunto com nosso sócio Marcos Maia.

Reforma tributária: alívio nas multas não afasta risco de perda de créditos
Imprensa

Reforma tributária: alívio nas multas não afasta risco de perda de créditos

12 de novembro de 2026

A promessa de não multar contribuintes que “errarem de boa-fé” na implantação da Reforma Tributária reduz o temor de autuações, mas deixa uma preocupação no ar. Como impedir que dificuldades de adaptação se transformem em imposto maior a recolher, créditos...

Reforma tributária exige corrigir a rota sem parar o navio
Artigos , Imprensa

Reforma tributária exige corrigir a rota sem parar o navio

9 de novembro de 2026

Em artigo publicado na Folha de S.Paulo, o prof. Eduardo Maneira aborda a necessidade de corrigir alguns pontos da reforma tributária, contudo, sem a necessidade de adiar a implantação das mudanças.

Imposto do Pecado: especialistas criticam atraso e regras complexas
Imprensa

Imposto do Pecado: especialistas criticam atraso e regras complexas

6 de novembro de 2026

A definição das alíquotas do IS (Imposto Seletivo), conhecido como "Imposto do Pecado", provocou críticas de especialistas em direito tributário. Eles apontam que o governo demorou a estabelecer as regras, criou fórmulas complexas para calcular a cobrança e deixou pouco...

Como funciona uma recuperação extrajudicial?
Imprensa

Como funciona uma recuperação extrajudicial?

23 de outubro de 2026

O jornal Monitor Mercantil conversou com Lucas Mayall, sócio do Maneira Advogados com atuação em processos de insolvência e de reestruturação de dívidas, sobre o funcionamento de uma recuperação extrajudicial.

Split payment vira disputa eleitoral; mas como de fato o mecanismo vai funcionar?
Imprensa

Split payment vira disputa eleitoral; mas como de fato o mecanismo vai funcionar?

20 de outubro de 2026

O split payment, sistema de apuração e recolhimento automático de impostos que será implementado com a reforma tributária, se tornou recentemente um tema em disputa na polarização eleitoral

Contato

Fale conosco


Preencha o formulário para falar com nossa equipe ou ligue, agora mesmo, para o escritório mais próximo!

Cidades

Rio de janeiro

Rio de janeiro

Av. Presidente Wilson, 231, 25° andar, Centro

(21) 2222-9008
São Paulo

São Paulo

Rua Professor Atílio de Innocenti, 165, 13º andar, Itaim Bibi

(11) 3062-2607
Brasília

Brasília

SHIS QL 08, Conjunto 01, Casa 11, Lago Sul

(61) 3224-2627
Belo Horizonte

Belo Horizonte

Av. Getúlio Vargas, 671, 13º andar, Funcionários

(31) 3190-0480